University of Notre Dame
MorrisseyCA022012D.pdf (1.65 MB)

Peace or War? Religion in the Debate Before the Iraq War

Download (1.65 MB)
posted on 2012-02-03, 00:00 authored by Christopher A. Morrissey
In this dissertation, I analyze religious actors debating the decision to go to war in Iraq in 2003 as well as the religious cultural dimensions of the larger public discussion. I argue that one cannot adequately explain the country's entry into the war without understanding the role of public Christianity in the argument for it. Furthermore, by analyzing elite religious advocacy both opposed and in favor of the conflict, I theorize the sets of identity relations and cultural repertoires that explain whether religious advocates will support or criticize state-sponsored violence. I find that the varying identity relations between religion, nation, and state largely predict religious advocates' positions on the war. Given these basic religious positions, I then explicate the constellation of symbolic codes that inform and sustain the basic positions of religious advocates vis-ÌÊ-vis war. These include the nature and constitution of political order, the nature of evil, the role of peace' particularly as it relates to the political order, the proper object of Christian love, and the value and practicality of nonviolence in the world. Additionally, I analyze patterns of discourse that differentiated between war supporters and war opponents' war supporters used less secular discourse than war opponents. I find that the social and political context primarily explains the particularly religious tenor of these actors. Advocates' sense of identity and their expertise influenced how they participated in the debate. Finally, I find the social sources of these distinct positions. Significant social contact with victims of structural violence tended to lead advocates to positions against the war. The dissertation concludes with a consideration of the direct contributions of this dissertation to academic understandings of religion, politics, war, and peace as well as its contributions to knowledge about public religion's relations to the politics of war and peace in America and our understanding of the relations between religion and violence.


Date Modified


Defense Date


Research Director(s)

Mary Ellen Konieczny

Committee Members

Lyn Spillman Robert Fishman


  • Doctor of Philosophy

Degree Level

  • Doctoral Dissertation


  • English

Alternate Identifier



University of Notre Dame

Program Name

  • Sociology

Usage metrics



    No categories selected


    Ref. manager