University of Notre Dame
Browse
ChoiEK072021T.pdf (456.88 kB)

New World Order? Thucydides' Speeches and the Breakdown of Greek Interstate Relations

Download (456.88 kB)
thesis
posted on 2021-07-12, 00:00 authored by Eleanor K. Choi

This thesis examines the historiographical treatment of interstate relations in Thucydides’ History of the Peloponnesian War and seeks to apply this treatment of diplomatic rhetoric to a historical understanding of fifth-century Greek perceptions of their inter-poleis condition.

I analyze three sets of speeches from the first, third, and sixth books of Thucydides’ History of the Peloponnesian War: the speeches of the Corcyraeans and the Corinthians at Athens, the Plataean Debate, and the speeches of Nicias and Alcibiades to the Athenian Assembly on the proposed Sicilian Expedition. After investigating a passage from the preface, in order to demonstrate how Thucydides views his speeches as both crucial and unclear when attempting to understand the War’s αἴτιαι (1.23.6), I examine the speeches in light of how Thucydidean rhetorical strategies highlight Athenian and Spartan rejection of moral aspects of negotiation of interstate relations, namely the values of justice and reciprocity, balancing power, and restraint. By subverting assumptions about how such older, established methods of diplomacy between poleis have historically functioned successfully, Thucydides is able to drive forward his narrative about the death of interstate relations during the War. Finally, I attempt to show how the speeches are designed to influence the ideologies of Thucydides’ readers, his fellow Greek contemporaries, about warfare in a negative way—regarding the inefficacy of pursuing positive interstate relations and the general futility of striving for peace.

History

Date Modified

2021-09-03

Defense Date

2021-07-12

CIP Code

  • 16.1200

Research Director(s)

Christopher A. Baron

Committee Members

Aldo Tagliabue David Hernandez

Degree

  • Master of Arts

Degree Level

  • Master's Thesis

Alternate Identifier

1266225947

Library Record

6113800

OCLC Number

1266225947

Program Name

  • Classics

Usage metrics

    Masters Theses

    Categories

    No categories selected

    Keywords

    Exports

    RefWorks
    BibTeX
    Ref. manager
    Endnote
    DataCite
    NLM
    DC