A Conscience Safe for Politics: Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau, and the Formation of the Modern Conscience

Doctoral Dissertation
Thumbnail

Abstract

The Wars of Religion that followed the Reformation raised fundamental questions regarding citizens’ competing religious, conscientious, and political obligations. In particular, Early Modern philosophers witnessed the potentially destabilizing nature of conscience-objections for legal and political order. In response, thinkers like Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau reevaluated Medieval Christian epistemologies of conscience – what conscience means and what access to truth it gives to individuals – to make conscience “safe” for politics. These innovations had profound implications for both the epistemology of conscience and the freedom of conscience in modern political societies.

First, I show how of all Early Modern political thinkers, Hobbes most clearly and radically identified the danger that individual conscience-claims pose for political stability and set the stage for Early Modern discourse on conscience. Next, I present Locke’s solution to the problem identified by Hobbes, and demonstrate that Locke’s advocacy of religious toleration and freedom of conscience rests on a fundamental shift in the epistemology of conscience and thus, for the relevancy of conscience for political life. Last, I argue that in contrast with Hobbes and Locke, Rousseau presents a much stronger – though no less modern – epistemology of conscience, while presenting the fundamental conflict between conscience and political society. What resulted from these thinkers are three distinct modern approaches to conscience which continue to influence the way liberal democracies understand and navigate conflicts between duties of conscience and duties of citizenship.

Attributes

Attribute NameValues
Author Robert John Burton
Contributor Michael P. Zuckert, Research Director
Degree Level Doctoral Dissertation
Degree Discipline Political Science
Degree Name Doctor of Philosophy
Banner Code
  • PHD-POLS

Defense Date
  • 2020-08-21

Submission Date 2020-12-07
Subject
  • Bonaventure

  • Calvin

  • Epistemology

  • Aquinas

  • Hobbes

  • Emile

  • Moral Epistemology

  • Social Contract

  • Concience

  • Rousseau

  • Locke

  • De Cive

  • Luther

  • Moral Letters

  • Freedom of Conscience

  • Essay Concerning Human Understanding

Language
  • English

Record Visibility Public
Content License
  • All rights reserved

Departments and Units
Catalog Record

Files

Please Note: You may encounter a delay before a download begins. Large or infrequently accessed files can take several minutes to retrieve from our archival storage system.