The Stranger's Knowledge: Political Knowledge in Plato's Statesman

Doctoral Dissertation

Abstract

This dissertation examines the Platonic view of the nature of political knowledge, its relations to other forms of knowledge, and its alienation from the political community. It is structured as a commentary on two Platonic dialogues: parts of the Sophist and all of the Statesman.

I first contextualize the question of political knowledge in relation to the questions of the nature of philosophy and sophistry with which it is intimately bound in the Sophist. There, philosophy is shown to be different from political knowledge; it is at best a striving for such knowledge. I then carefully dissect the way in which the nature of this knowledge is brought to light in the Statesman. There political knowledge is shown to be a form of human care with a troubled relationship to practice, which is the province of the technai or what we might now call “technology.” Political order thus emerges in the Statesman from the proper regulation of all forms of human know-how.

Yet this achievement is both improbable and highly unstable. The statesman appears as a messianic figure, an accident of both nature and society – a perfect stranger – whose knowledge is impossibly scarce and necessarily suspect. His knowledge and his presence are in tension with the basic need of the city for law: the city needs its independence, but the law is a poor substitute for the statesman.

I conclude by confronting some of the criticisms raised against the Platonic conception of political knowledge by various thinkers, starting with Aristotle. I argue that many of these criticisms are based on a misunderstanding of the relationship of political knowledge to practice, or rather, of the conceptual function of the notion of political knowledge as a critical ideal of practice. I also sketch some ways in which the Eleatic Stranger’s ideas about political knowledge are fleshed out and institutionalized in the Laws.

Attributes

Attribute NameValues
URN
  • etd-03172006-111218

Author Xavier Marquez
Advisor Catherine Zuckert
Contributor Catherine Zuckert, Committee Chair
Contributor David OConnor, Committee Member
Contributor Fred Dallmayr, Committee Member
Contributor Walter Nicgorski, Committee Member
Degree Level Doctoral Dissertation
Degree Discipline Political Science
Degree Name PhD
Defense Date
  • 2005-11-03

Submission Date 2006-03-17
Country
  • United States of America

Subject
  • Knowledge

  • Philosophy

  • Plato

  • Sophist

  • Politics

  • Statesman

Publisher
  • University of Notre Dame

Language
  • English

Record Visibility Public
Content License
  • All rights reserved

Departments and Units

Files

Please Note: You may encounter a delay before a download begins. Large or infrequently accessed files can take several minutes to retrieve from our archival storage system.