Kirkland and Harden -- Transparency and Policy Responsiveness 4-8-20.pdf (2.34 MB)
Does Transparency Improve Political Representation?
journal contribution
posted on 2020-05-05, 00:00 authored by Jeff HardenGovernments around the world adopt transparency reforms to facilitate accountability. In principle, open proceedings provide citizens with valuable information to evaluate elected officials' decisionmaking, which incentives lawmakers to follow mass preferences when choosing policies. However, the public's general lack of knowledge and engagement with the political process may weaken the power of open information, and perhaps instead allow citizens and groups with extreme views to exert relatively more influence in policymaking. We test these competing theoretical perspectives in the context of American state legislatures. We leverage temporal variation in state 'sunshine law' adoptions and legislative exemptions to estimate the effects of transparency on a key element of representation—aggregate policy responsiveness. We find a consistent pattern of precisely-estimated negligible effects; legislative transparency exerts minimal influence on the link between mass preferences and state policy. We conclude that, despite their promise, transparency reforms may be insufficient for mitigating democratic deficits.
History
Date Modified
2020-05-05Language
- English
Publisher
University of Notre DameUsage metrics
Categories
No categories selectedKeywords
Licence
Exports
RefWorks
BibTeX
Ref. manager
Endnote
DataCite
NLM
DC